adambeneschan
2/11/2014 5:04:00 PM
On Monday, February 10, 2014 9:22:22 PM UTC-8, ttw...@att.net wrote:
> > We don't play a forcing NT.
>
>
>
> Then I would say that partner should have passed 3D. Lacking a specific agreement (like 2/1 game forcing, etc.) the sequence 1S-2D, 3C-3D shows a hand that really does not like Spades or Clubs and is only good for Diamonds (at this point).
Sorry, I don't think 1S-2D-3C-3D is passable. 3C really should be GF. Because of that, I completely disagree that 3D shows a hand that is "only good for diamonds".
> Partner has shown 5 Spades and 4 Clubs (at least) and nearly game forcing strength; however, your hand is a real misfit. Goren suggested that even the whiff of a misfit is a signal to pass. Misfits do not generally play well in NT either.
But **North** has no reason to believe the hand is a misfit. Since 1S-2D-3C is a strong bid, South could bid 3D with a hand of any strength, including one that intends to drive to slam.
-- Adam