KalElFan
5/15/2012 12:36:00 AM
"Hunter (Hunter)" wrote in message
news:4fb129e6.17549414@news.optonline.net...
> On Sun, 13 May 2012 21:27:08 -0400, "KalElFan"
> <kalelfan@yanospamhoo.com> wrote:
>
>> The characters all seem to have their Storybrooke memories
>> though, along with their fairy tale memories. Snow is walking
>> along the street, seeming doubtful about the memories and it
>> isn't until Charming calls her "Snow" that she seems to realize
>> everyone has had their memories restored.
>
> That is how I read it to. The whole town is likely to be like that.
> Their real memories conflicting with the lives they have lead for the
> past 28 years and what they considered "impossible", so they are
> bewildered.
Right, but I think it probably doesn't seem like 28 years to most of
them. The exceptions are probably Jefferson, Gold and Regina.
Henry should also have sensed that time was off, because he aged
and caught up with other kids like Paige. Not sure they'll ever go
there and try to explain that though.
>> So this season finale also does an end run around the huge
>> problem they would have had with ever wiping all of their
>> Storybrooke memories. They're all continuous characters at
>> this point and will presumably remain so.
>
> I don't think that was ever a problem. Only a few selected people
> knew, those who had control of Magic, Regina, Gold and Jefferson;
> and those created by magic like August.
I was mainly referring to some of the early discussions here about
the end game of the show. The "happy ending" isn't having their
Storybrooke memories erased, it's at least having the choice to
keep those memories even if they return to the fairy tale world
one day. So yes, this was a creative issue the show would have
had. It was a given the amnesia would get resolved at some point
and they'd remember the fairy tale world. But a pure reset would
have had them forget Storybrooke, and again I don't think that
would've worked for the viewership.
The "daze" of Snow and others during the transition very strongly
suggests they now have full memories of both realms. I think that's
the right creative decision for the show and it's now behind them.