On Mar 23, 7:37 am, "Gerard" <ghendriksen_nosp...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> td <tomdedea...@mac.com> typed:
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> > On Mar 23, 5:57 am, "Gerard" <ghendriksen_nosp...@hotmail.com> wrote:
> > > td <tomdedea...@mac.com> typed:
>
> > > > On Mar 23, 1:06 am, Tassilo <david7ga...@aol.com> wrote:
> > > > > FWIW, the Casadesus/Rosbaud recording of Beethoven's Emperor
> > > > > Concerto has just been reissued on the label Newton Classics. I
> > > > > don't know anything about the quality of the transfer:
>
> > > > You don't have to wonder.
>
> > > > It is a Philips master and a Philips master would have been used.
>
> > > > Jesus!
>
> > > > I wonder if you check your Rice Crispies every morning to see if
> > > > they have any dust in them.
>
> > > > TD
>
> > > The question is fully legitimate.
> > > It has happened a few times that reissues by newton classics had
> > > deficiencies. I remember the Tchaikovsky symphonies by Markevich
> > > were reported here. But there was more.
>
> > I have no knowledge of such "deficiencies", Gerard. There may, of
> > course, be pressing defects in CDs from time to time. It happened much
> > more often with LPs, I seem to recall.
>
> > But Philips would not send out a faulty mastertape to Newton. No, not
> > ever.
>
> That could be right.
> But newton classics did screw it up a few times.
> Newton classics was to blame.
> The Tchaikovsky symphonies by Markevich case probably can still be found in the
> archives.
> AFAIK they (newton classics) corrected their mistakes in a new take. I don't
> know how the buyers of the defective sets were treated (if they could get
> replacements easily).
Usually these are replaced graciously and quickly. Mistakes are made
in any product. The point is to correct them.
But this is no reason to question the "master" used by Newton. They
officially license from Universal, so the only master they would use
would come from the company owning the repertoire. The Markevich
problems seem to have been in the manufacturing, not the mastering. I
certainly have no problems with my Markevich CDs, which are Philips
products manufactured in Hannover.
TD