Asp Forum - extconf.rb and dyld problem

David Plans Casal

4/6/2005 1:39:00 PM

hello people!

just trying to use extconf.rb script using mkmf to compile a bundle for
osx (some c++ libraries)

compilation is going ok and linking (even libstdc++) seems ok, but
invoking the shared bundle in IRB gives me:

dyld: ruby Undefined symbols:
<snip>
(long list of symbols)

could someone point at the most common reason this happens?

sorry for such n00b question, but just can't figure it out, tried
several different LDFLAGS options after googling, and currently have
the following options set:

if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
$CPPFLAGS += " -DUNIX"
$LDFLAGS += " -lstdc++ -L/usr/local/lib"
dir_config("fmod","/usr/local/include","/usr/local/lib")
end

if have_header("fmod.h")
if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
CONFIG["CC"] = "c++"
CONFIG["LDSHARED"].gsub!("cc","g++") #make sure you're using
g++ so it links libstdc++
CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++')
$create = true if have_library("fmod")
elsif have_library("fmod") #more than likely a linux box
CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++') #make sure c++ gets
linked properly
$create = true
end
end

any advice?

thanks!

david casal

11 Answers

Peter Wood

4/6/2005 2:33:00 PM

>hello people!
>
>just trying to use extconf.rb script using mkmf to compile a bundle
>for osx (some c++ libraries)
>
>compilation is going ok and linking (even libstdc++) seems ok, but
>invoking the shared bundle in IRB gives me:
>
>dyld: ruby Undefined symbols:
><snip>
>(long list of symbols)
>
>could someone point at the most common reason this happens?
>
>sorry for such n00b question, but just can't figure it out, tried
>several different LDFLAGS options after googling, and currently have
>the following options set:
>
>if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
> $CPPFLAGS += " -DUNIX"
> $LDFLAGS += " -lstdc++ -L/usr/local/lib"
> dir_config("fmod","/usr/local/include","/usr/local/lib")
>end
>
>if have_header("fmod.h")
> if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
> CONFIG["CC"] = "c++"
> CONFIG["LDSHARED"].gsub!("cc","g++") #make sure you're using
>g++ so it links libstdc++
> CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++')
> $create = true if have_library("fmod")
> elsif have_library("fmod") #more than likely a linux box
> CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++') #make sure c++ gets
>linked properly
> $create = true
> end
>end
>
>any advice?
>
>thanks!
>
>david casal

From your mail it looks as if you doing your best to use the C++
compiler rather than the standard C compiler. Won't you then be
subject to name mangling? Ruby is expecting certain elements under
standard names. If those names have been mangled by the C++ compiler
it won't find them.

nobu.nokada

4/6/2005 2:39:00 PM

Hi,

At Wed, 6 Apr 2005 22:39:23 +0900,
David Plans Casal wrote in [ruby-talk:137071]:
> sorry for such n00b question, but just can't figure it out, tried
> several different LDFLAGS options after googling, and currently have
> the following options set:

If you need libstdc++, using have_library instead would be best
right now.

have_library("stdc++")
dir_config("fmod", "/usr/local")

--
Nobu Nakada

Sam Roberts

4/6/2005 2:40:00 PM

Wrote David Plans Casal <dpc@davidcasal.com>, on Wed, Apr 06, 2005 at 10:39:23PM +0900:
> hello people!
>
> just trying to use extconf.rb script using mkmf to compile a bundle for
> osx (some c++ libraries)
>
> compilation is going ok and linking (even libstdc++) seems ok, but
> invoking the shared bundle in IRB gives me:
>
> dyld: ruby Undefined symbols:
> <snip>
> (long list of symbols)

Could you include some of the symbols?

Ruby expects an extension to have known entry points and those points
must be declared extern C, i.e. to have C linkage:

extern "C" void Init_MyClass(void);

...

void Init_MyClass(void)
{
...
}

could this be the problem?

Sam

> could someone point at the most common reason this happens?
>
> sorry for such n00b question, but just can't figure it out, tried
> several different LDFLAGS options after googling, and currently have
> the following options set:
>
> if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
> $CPPFLAGS += " -DUNIX"
> $LDFLAGS += " -lstdc++ -L/usr/local/lib"
> dir_config("fmod","/usr/local/include","/usr/local/lib")
> end
>
> if have_header("fmod.h")
> if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
> CONFIG["CC"] = "c++"
> CONFIG["LDSHARED"].gsub!("cc","g++") #make sure you're using
> g++ so it links libstdc++
> CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++')
> $create = true if have_library("fmod")
> elsif have_library("fmod") #more than likely a linux box
> CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++') #make sure c++ gets
> linked properly
> $create = true
> end
> end
>
> any advice?
>
> thanks!
>
> david casal
>
>

--
Sam Roberts <sroberts@certicom.com>

David Plans Casal

4/6/2005 2:52:00 PM

On 6 Apr 2005, at 15:33, Peter Wood wrote:

>> if have_header("fmod.h")
>> if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
>> CONFIG["CC"] = "c++"
>> CONFIG["LDSHARED"].gsub!("cc","g++") #make sure you're using
>> g++ so it links libstdc++
>> CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++')
>> $create = true if have_library("fmod")
>> elsif have_library("fmod") #more than likely a linux box
>> CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++') #make sure c++ gets
>> linked properly
>> $create = true
>> end
>> end
> From your mail it looks as if you doing your best to use the C++
> compiler rather than the standard C compiler. Won't you then be
> subject to name mangling? Ruby is expecting certain elements under
> standard names. If those names have been mangled by the C++ compiler
> it won't find them.

The libraries I'm trying to compile/link are C++, so I thought I -had-
to use the C++ compiler?

d

David Plans Casal

4/6/2005 2:58:00 PM

On 6 Apr 2005, at 15:38, nobu.nokada@softhome.net wrote:

>> sorry for such n00b question, but just can't figure it out, tried
>> several different LDFLAGS options after googling, and currently have
>> the following options set:
>
> If you need libstdc++, using have_library instead would be best
> right now.
>
> have_library("stdc++")
> dir_config("fmod", "/usr/local")

I included have_library("stdc++") in extconf.rb and took out the LDFLAG
stuff calling libstdc++ from there;

I get:

waldorf:~/Development/music/hail-ruby dc$ ./extconf.rb
checking for fmod.h... yes
checking for main() in -lstdc++... yes
checking for main() in -lfmod... yes
creating Makefile

After running make, the bottom of the output reads:

g++ -dynamic -bundle -undefined suppress -flat_namespace
-L'/usr/local/lib' -L'/usr/local/lib' -o hail.bundle Audio.o Channel.o
Channel2D.o Channel3D.o ChannelEax.o EaxMaterial.o Hail.o Listener.o
ListenerEax.o Log.o Manager.o Memory.o RbVector3.o Sample.o Scheduler.o
Signal.o Sound.o SparseSwitcher.o Stream.o Timer.o Vector3.o -lruby
-lfmod -lstdc++ -ldl -lobjc

And the output of 'sudo make install' gives;

install -c -p -m 0755 hail.bundle
/usr/local/lib/ruby/site_ruby/1.8/powerpc-darwin
install -c -p -m 0644 ./lib/hail/AudioExtensions.rb
/usr/local/lib/ruby/site_ruby/1.8/hail
install -c -p -m 0644 ./lib/hail/CrowdSynth.rb
/usr/local/lib/ruby/site_ruby/1.8/hail
install -c -p -m 0644 ./lib/hail/EAX.rb
/usr/local/lib/ruby/site_ruby/1.8/hail
install -c -p -m 0644 ./lib/hail/Log.rb
/usr/local/lib/ruby/site_ruby/1.8/hail

However, to answer Sam's question below, I'm still getting 'dyld: ruby
Undefined symbols'...will list some below:

On 6 Apr 2005, at 15:39, Sam Roberts wrote:

> Could you include some of the symbols?
>
> Ruby expects an extension to have known entry points and those points
> must be declared extern C, i.e. to have C linkage:

waldorf:~/Development/music/hail-ruby dc$ irb
irb(main):001:0> require 'hail'
dyld: ruby Undefined symbols:
_AbsoluteToDuration
_AddDurationToAbsolute
_BitClr
_BitTst
_CloseOpenTransportInContext
_Dequeue
_DisposePtr
_Enqueue
_Fix2Long

<snip>

_SndDoImmediate
_SndNewC_SndSoundManagerVersion
_UpTime
_YieldToAnyThread
__MPIsFullyInitialized
Trace/BPT trap

Unfortunately, I'm not sure what Sam means by 'entry points', due my
total lack of C and newbie programmer skills in Ruby...

Does this throw more light on the problem?

Hope you guys see something I don't...

d

Peter Wood

4/6/2005 3:01:00 PM

>On 6 Apr 2005, at 15:33, Peter Wood wrote:
>
>>>if have_header("fmod.h")
>>> if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
>>> CONFIG["CC"] = "c++"
>>> CONFIG["LDSHARED"].gsub!("cc","g++") #make sure you're
>>>using g++ so it links libstdc++
>>> CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++')
>>> $create = true if have_library("fmod")
>>> elsif have_library("fmod") #more than likely a linux box
>>> CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++') #make sure c++ gets
>>>linked properly
>>> $create = true
>>> end
>>>end
>>From your mail it looks as if you doing your best to use the C++
>>compiler rather than the standard C compiler. Won't you then be
>>subject to name mangling? Ruby is expecting certain elements under
>>standard names. If those names have been mangled by the C++
>>compiler it won't find them.
>
>The libraries I'm trying to compile/link are C++, so I thought I
>-had- to use the C++ compiler?
>
>d

Apologies, I should have been more specific. Where you mix C and C++
code you must explicitly pick out the elements that to be treated in
the C way from those that will be handled in the C++ way. Another
mail on this topic has already referred to marking the initialization
function with extern "C". You may have to do this for other elements
as well, although an exact list of what requires it will depend on
the symbols that are missing.

lucsky

4/6/2005 3:23:00 PM

David Plans Casal <dpc@davidcasal.com> wrote:

> waldorf:~/Development/music/hail-ruby dc$ irb
> irb(main):001:0> require 'hail'
> dyld: ruby Undefined symbols:
> _AbsoluteToDuration
> _AddDurationToAbsolute
> _BitClr
> _BitTst
> _CloseOpenTransportInContext
> _Dequeue
> _DisposePtr
> _Enqueue
> _Fix2Long
>
> <snip>
>
> _SndDoImmediate
> _SndNewC_SndSoundManagerVersion
> _UpTime
> _YieldToAnyThread
> __MPIsFullyInitialized
> Trace/BPT trap

These furiously look like Carbon calls. You should try to link against
the Carbon framework using the '-framework Carbon' in the link options.

--
Luc Heinrich - lucsky@mac.com

David Plans Casal

4/6/2005 3:27:00 PM

I include my extconf.rb here complete, for reference, in case it helps:

#!/usr/local/bin/ruby
require 'mkmf'

$create = false

if ARGV.include?("--help")
print <<EOF
--with-fmod-include specify directory for fmod include files
--with-fmod-lib specify directory for fmod library files
EOF
exit(0)
end

if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
$CPPFLAGS += " -DUNIX"
$LDFLAGS += " "
dir_config("fmod","/usr/local/include","/usr/local/lib")
end

if have_header("fmod.h")
if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
CONFIG["CC"] = "c++"
CONFIG["LDSHARED"].gsub!("cc","g++")
CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++')
have_library("stdc++")
$create = true if have_library("fmod")
elsif have_library("fmod") #more than likely a linux box
CONFIG['LDSHARED'].gsub!('gcc','g++') #make sure c++ gets
linked properly
$create = true
end
end
if $create
create_makefile("hail")
else
puts 'your system is not correctly setup to build hail'
puts 'look in mkmf.log to figure out why.'
end

David Plans Casal

4/6/2005 3:31:00 PM

On 6 Apr 2005, at 16:01, Peter Wood wrote:

>> The libraries I'm trying to compile/link are C++, so I thought I
>> -had- to use the C++ compiler?
> Apologies, I should have been more specific. Where you mix C and C++
> code you must explicitly pick out the elements that to be treated in
> the C way from those that will be handled in the C++ way. Another mail
> on this topic has already referred to marking the initialization
> function with extern "C". You may have to do this for other elements
> as well, although an exact list of what requires it will depend on the
> symbols that are missing.

I'm sorry if this is a waste of your time (I mean that I may not even
understand your advice)...but the thing is this set of ruby bindings
came from the author, who is able to compile them in linux just fine,
and comes with ruby examples that use the linked c++ libraries he
wrote.

What I'm wondering here is: perhaps my problem is simply to do with the
darwin platform differences with linux, and that extconf.rb was written
for linux?

I say this because I hope that's the case ;-) ... since if the
problem is what you outline, I'm probably not going to be able to do
much about it...

Cheers,

David

David Plans Casal

4/6/2005 3:32:00 PM

On 6 Apr 2005, at 16:24, Luc Heinrich wrote:

> David Plans Casal <dpc@davidcasal.com> wrote:
>
>> _AbsoluteToDuration
>> _AddDurationToAbsolute

> These furiously look like Carbon calls. You should try to link against
> the Carbon framework using the '-framework Carbon' in the link options.

Do you mean like this?

if RUBY_PLATFORM =~ /darwin/
$CPPFLAGS += " -DUNIX"
$LDFLAGS += " -framework Carbon"
dir_config("fmod","/usr/local/include","/usr/local/lib")
end

d

comp.lang.ruby

extconf.rb and dyld problem

David Plans Casal

Peter Wood

nobu.nokada

Sam Roberts

David Plans Casal

David Plans Casal

Peter Wood

lucsky

David Plans Casal

David Plans Casal

David Plans Casal

x Login to ForumsZone