microsoft.public.dotnet.framework.remoting

Ice

8/30/2004 3:54:00 PM

did you work with different channels?

ice
"Stuart Campbell" <scampbell@citynetworks-withoutthisantispamstuff-.co.uk>
wrote in message news:b21201c488f3$11f5fa20$a401280a@phx.gbl...
> Hi,
>
> I have been doing some Remoting vs. Web Services tests for
> the architecture of a new project. I have performed my
> tests using both .NET v1.1 and .NET v2.0 Beta 1 and I have
> had some confusing results in v2.0. Either I am not
> configuring it properly or there is a bug where it might
> be using SOAP formatting even when configured to use
> binary formatting.
>
> The test is set up like this:
> -----------------------------
> ASP.NET Client App --> wellknown singlecall object hosted
> in IIS --> SQL Server
>
> Both client and server are configured using the
> <system.runtime.remoting> section in web.config:
>
> Channel: HTTP
> Formatter: binary
> -----------------------------
>
> Here are the confusing results I got when returning a 1000
> row dataset.
>
> v1.1:
> SOAP - 29.0 secs
> Binary - 3.5 secs
>
> v2.0 Beta 1:
> SOAP - 29.0 secs
> Binary - 29.0 secs !!!!
>
> Are there any changes to remoting config in v2.0 or is
> this a bug?
> NOTE: I haven't checked to see that soap packets are
> coming back...I'm just assuming because of the figures.
>
> I'll include config below.
>
> If anyone can shed some light on this I'd be very grateful.
>
> TIA
>
> Stuart
>
> Client:
> -------
> <system.runtime.remoting>
> <application>
> <client>
> <wellknown
> type="MyNamespace.SampleBusinessComponent, Biz"
> url="http://server:80/TestA2005-
> Biz/SampleBusinessComponent.rem"/>
> </client>
> <channels>
> <channel ref="http">
> <clientProviders>
> <formatter
> ref="binary"/>
> </clientProviders>
> </channel>
> </channels>
> </application>
> </system.runtime.remoting>
>
> Server:
> -------
> <system.runtime.remoting>
> <application>
> <service>
> <wellknown
> mode="SingleCall"
>
> objectUri="SampleBusinessComponent.rem"
>
> type="MyNamespace.SampleBusinessComponent, Biz"/>
> </service>
> <channels>
> <channel ref="http">
> <serverProviders>
> <formatter
> ref="binary"/>
> </serverProviders>
> </channel>
> </channels>
> </application>
> </system.runtime.remoting>
>
> --------