dsharavi
1/30/2009 12:05:00 AM
> > > > > On Jan 28, 3:35 am, The Endeavor <The_Endea...@Noaddress.com> wrote:
> > > > > > The guy has not got a clue, FATAH was already in power.
> > > > "dsharavi" <dshara...@hotmail.com> wrote
> > > > > It seems Pappe hasn't a clue about a number of things. A few
> > > > > corrections to Pappe's cluelessness:
>
> > > > > -Palestine in the 19th century did not have a “flourishing
> > > > > Palestinian Arab population”.
> > > > > --Theodor Herzl did not found Zionism in the late 1880s.
> > > > > --Zionism never contained an “ideology of ethnic superiority”.
> > > > > --The Biluim were not led by Moshe Lilienblum and Leon Pinsker, and
> > > > > did not establish “the first Zionist settlements in Palestine”.
> > > > > --Tel Aviv was not “founded on a Saturday morning in July 1907”.
> > > > > --There was no Anglo-French plan for the occupation of Palestine in
> > > > > 1912.
> > > > > --T.E. Lawrence was not a party to the 1916 McMahon-Hussein
> > > > > correspondence.
> > > > > --The Hebrew University was not built in 1920.
> > > > > --The British did not accord Jews “preferential treatment” over
> > > > > Arabs,
> > > > > nor did the British help Jews create the Hagana.
> > > > > --Ben-Gurion did not lead the Zionist Movement from the 1920s to the
> > > > > 1960s, nor was he chairman of the Jewish Agency in 1929.
> > > > > --The Arab Higher Committee was not “established by 1934”.
> > > > > --The Palmach was not active in the 1930s; it did not exist.
> > > > > --The Mufti did not flee Palestine in 1938.
> > > > > --The Arab Higher Committee never tried to "negotiate a principled
> > > > > settlement with the Jewish Agency".
> > > > > --Ben-Gurion never said, “I am for compulsory transfer. I do not see
> > > > > anything immoral in it.”
> > > > > --The UNSCOP presented its report on 31 August 1947, not on 29
> > > > > November 1947.
> > > > > --The partition resolution did not have “an equal number of
> > > > > supporters
> > > > > and detractors”.
> > > > > --No “series of attacks” on Arab villages began “in early December
> > > > > 1947”; Arab attacks on, and massacre of, Jews began the day following
> > > > > the partition vote.
> > > > > --Arabs weren't expelled within 12 days of the partition resolution.
> > > > > --No “forced expulsions” of Arabs began in “mid-February 1948.”
> > > > > --The Palmach did not fight the British in 1948, nor was it commanded
> > > > > by Moshe Dayan.
> > > > > --Ben-Gurion did not meet with “leading Zionists and young Jewish
> > > > > military officers” on 10 March 1948, or at any other time, to
> > > > > finalize
> > > > > plans to “ethnically cleanse” Palestine.
> > > > > --Plan D did not provide for mass murder or for the “forcible
> > > > > expulson” of hundreds of thousands of Arabs, and there was no "master
> > > > > plan to rid the future Jewish state of as many Palestinians as
> > > > > possible."
> > > > > --Jews did not expel 250,000 Arabs while under British rule.
> > > > > --The Jewish Agency did not declare the state of Israel on 15 May
> > > > > 1948.
> > > > > --The Arabs did not invade with “small, ill-equipped forces”, nor did
> > > > > they confront a “superior, well-armed Israeli military.”
> > > > > --Jewish forces “on the eve of battle” did not comprise an air force,
> > > > > a navy, units of tanks, or heavy artillery.
> > > > > --There was no “tacit collusion” with the Jordanians which
> > > > > “neutralized” the Legion.
> > > > > --The first truce was not 'signed' on 10 June 1948, or on any other
> > > > > date.
> > > > > --800,000 Arabs were not expelled in six months, nor were 531 Arab
> > > > > villages destroyed.
> > > > > --“Successful Israeli campaigns” did not continue, nor lead to the
> > > > > Jews' “complete control of Palestine”, in August 1948; nor was the
> > > > > war
> > > > > “completed by October”.
> > > > > --The Jews did not in 1949 create “forced labor camps” for
> > > > > “Palestinians”.
>
> > > > > Corections to all of Pappe's errata would fill another volume -- and a
> > > > > much larger one than either of Pappe's little ones.
> > > > > Deborah
> > > On Jan 28, 1:19 pm, HHW <coaster132...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> > > > Now you have us in a bind, Deborah. Given that no one who knows >your
> > > > "work" believes a word you say, what's left but to ignore this?
> > > "dsharavi" <dshara...@hotmail.com> wrote
> > > >Given that you ignore facts anyway, your dishonest and cowardly
> > > >evasion is only to be expected of a propaganda parrot such as
> > > >yourself.
> > > >The FACTS remain that your beloved Pappe -- whose works I doubt you've
> > > >actually read -- is such a poor scholar, or careless liar, that he
> > > >never thought to correct his glaring errors. Here they are again:
> > On Jan 29, 9:13 am, "Jason P" <jasp...@NoSpam.gmail.com> wrote:
:> > > You're a moron Deborah.
> On Jan 29, 8:48 am, drahcir <justrichardsmu...@gmail.com> wrote:
> > LOL! As if there isn't a soul here, HHW included, who isn't thinking
> > right now "jason calling deborah a moron is like Gary Coleman calling
> > Wilt Chamberlain a pipsqueak." A child like Jason can't see himself
> > clearly - his thinking isn't much beyond "wahwah, change me, mommy".
> > All your assertions are solely based on
> > > Jew-Zionist-Nazi versions of real event that you or your Jew friends know
> > > little about, or want to know anything about.
On Jan 29, 3:26 pm, HHW <coaster132...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> Actually they are simply assertions.
Wrong, as usual, Hunter. They are FACTS, as opposed to the drivel
spewed by Pappe.
>She wants us to spend hours
> trying to figure out which passages are referred to if any in Pappe's
> "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine" and then how it is that they are
> dishonest.
Now you're being your usual cowardly and backpedaling self, Hunter.
"Spend hours trying to figure out...." You have got to be kidding. At
a bare 300 pages, it takes only a few hours to read Pappe's spew. His
misrepresentations of the facts, and the corrections thereto listed
above, are quite verifiable. Your unwillingness to address the
foregoing is a measure of your ignorance, your hypocrisy, and your
cowardice.
>You'll recall that she has yet to reply to the Mearsheimer
> & Walt complete demolition of Benny Morris' review of the Israeli
> history parts of their famous book. She just moves on to another
> series of misreprestntations, this time presented as her own.
You know, Hunter, for a lawyer, you're singularly obtuse. I already
replied to Mearsheimer's alleged "complete demolitiion". And, FYI, it
wasn't Mearsheimer & Walt. It was only Mearsheimer. And Mearsheimer,
like you, was wrong as usual.
>Morris
> is now demonstrably an Israeli whore
Wrong again, Hunter. The whore here is Pappe. Another is Mearsheimer.
And then there's you, their self-appointed pimp.
Pappe did indeed make the following assertions, which I corrected.
Surely you, having read his book, can easily find the passages.
> > > -Palestine in the 19th century did not have a “flourishing
> > > Palestinian Arab population”.
> > > --Theodor Herzl did not found Zionism in the late 1880s.
> > > --Zionism never contained an “ideology of ethnic superiority”.
> > > --The Biluim were not led by Moshe Lilienblum and Leon Pinsker, and
> > > did not establish “the first Zionist settlements in Palestine”.
> > > --Tel Aviv was not “founded on a Saturday morning in July 1907”.
> > > --There was no Anglo-French plan for the occupation of Palestine in
> > > 1912.
> > > --T.E. Lawrence was not a party to the 1916 McMahon-Hussein
> > > correspondence.
> > > --The Hebrew University was not built in 1920.
> > > --The British did not accord Jews “preferential treatment” over
> > > Arabs, nor did the British help Jews create the Hagana.
> > > --Ben-Gurion did not lead the Zionist Movement from the 1920s to the
> > > 1960s, nor was he chairman of the Jewish Agency in 1929.
> > > --The Arab Higher Committee was not “established by 1934”.
> > > --The Palmach was not active in the 1930s; it did not exist.
> > > --The Mufti did not flee Palestine in 1938.
> > > --The Arab Higher Committee never tried to "negotiate a principled
> > > settlement with the Jewish Agency".
> > > --Ben-Gurion never said, “I am for compulsory transfer. I do not see
> > > anything immoral in it.”
> > > --The UNSCOP presented its report on 31 August 1947, not on 29
> > > November 1947.
> > > --The partition resolution did not have “an equal number of
> > > supporters and detractors”.
> > > --No “series of attacks” on Arab villages began “in early December
> > > 1947”; Arab attacks on, and massacre of, Jews began the day following
> > > the partition vote.
> > > --Arabs weren't expelled within 12 days of the partition resolution.
> > > --No “forced expulsions” of Arabs began in “mid-February 1948.”
> > > --The Palmach did not fight the British in 1948, nor was it commanded
> > > by Moshe Dayan.
> > > --Ben-Gurion did not meet with “leading Zionists and young Jewish
> > > military officers” on 10 March 1948, or at any other time, to
> > > finalize plans to “ethnically cleanse” Palestine.
> > > --Plan D did not provide for mass murder or for the “forcible
> > > expulson” of hundreds of thousands of Arabs, and there was no "master
> > > plan to rid the future Jewish state of as many Palestinians as
> > > possible."
> > > --Jews did not expel 250,000 Arabs while under British rule.
> > > --The Jewish Agency did not declare the state of Israel on 15 May
> > > 1948.
> > > --The Arabs did not invade with “small, ill-equipped forces”, nor did
> > > they confront a “superior, well-armed Israeli military.”
> > > --Jewish forces “on the eve of battle” did not comprise an air force,
> > > a navy, units of tanks, or heavy artillery.
> > > --There was no “tacit collusion” with the Jordanians which
> > > “neutralized” the Legion.
> > > --The first truce was not 'signed' on 10 June 1948, or on any other
> > > date.
> > > --800,000 Arabs were not expelled in six months, nor were 531 Arab
> > > villages destroyed.
> > > --“Successful Israeli campaigns” did not continue, nor lead to the
> > > Jews' “complete control of Palestine”, in August 1948; nor was the
> > > war “completed by October”.
> > > --The Jews did not in 1949 create “forced labor camps” for
> > > “Palestinians”.
>
> > > >Corections to all of Pappe's errata would fill another volume -- and a
> > > >much larger one than either of Pappe's little ones.
> > > >Deborah
> > > You're a moron Deborah. All your assertions are solely based on
> > > Jew-Zionist-Nazi versions of real event that you or your Jew friends know
> > > little about, or want to know anything about.
> > > Go slither back under your spawn covered rock!
> What would we do without the Deborah types?
Wallow in ignorance, as usual.
[gratuitous insults snipped]]
Deborah