Steve Willner
7/9/2014 9:36:00 PM
On 2014-06-27 6:49 PM, Mark Brader wrote:
> Well, he could have applied Law 64B7, which specifies that if both
> sides revoke on the board then the table result stands.
No, L64B7 says there are no _rectification_ tricks. L64C still applies,
though.
> You were applying for a judgement under Law 64C
Right.
> which is at the director's discretion
Not exactly. It's a judgment ruling whether penalty tricks compensate
for the revoke's damage or not, but once that judgment is made, giving
an adjusted score or not is automatic. It can be a split score and can
be weighted in some jurisdictions.
I didn't bother to follow the exact sequence of events after the revoke,
but L64C and three tricks to the defense seem automatic.
--
Help keep our newsgroup healthy; please don't feed the trolls.
Steve Willner Phone 617-495-7123 swillner@nhcc.net
Cambridge, MA 02138 USA